The 5 Ways to Maximize Your Marketing Amidst Customers’ Privacy Concerns

Digital marketing is not the shiny new object it was a decade ago, but is still a crucial piece of any business’ tool kit. Privacy concerns from users have pushed tech giants like Meta, Google, Apple and others to adopt stricter security features, making it more difficult for user activity to be tracked online thus providing a conundrum for marketers.

That is great news for the consumer who is wary of one too many oddly specific and prescient ad placements. It’s not as welcome news for marketing professionals who have poured millions of dollars into digital because of how granular they could get with ad targeting and the detailed reporting that followed.

Apple introduced App Tracking Transparency in 2021, an explicit opt out option presented to iPhone users regarding in-app activity tracking, which threw a wrench into many marketer’s digital strategies because it fundamentally altered how campaigns on platforms like Facebook and Instagram were run. Facebook itself has claimed the iOS privacy change will cost them $10 Billion in 2022 alone.  

Just a few years ago a marketer could target a hundred people on Facebook and track 10 definitive conversions from that original audience. Over time Facebook increased the minimum size of a custom audience that one could create with externally uploaded information (i.e. email lists) due to data scraping concerns. The nexus event of these privacy concerns originate from the disaster that was Cambridge Analytica

News stories like that, the trend of social media algorithms favoring sensational and engaging content above all else, and even Congressional hearings, have led to public pushback, putting tech giants on their heels forcing them to adapt. 

Marketers, as is their nature, were forced to do the same.  

So now with the privacy and security concerns of users leading to changes made by the platforms in response, the easy days are a thing of the past. 

That doesn’t mean that digital marketing is any less effective though. It just means every business needs to go beyond just the numbers of what the CPA is on this creative targeting that audience vs another. 

Here are the Top 5 Ways to Maximize Your Marketing Amidst Customers’ Privacy Concerns

1.) Influencer Marketing 

The effectiveness of Influencer Marketing lies in the ability to partner with a personality that consumers already trust and admire. Partnering with creators allows a brand to go beyond direct marketing and provides a warm referral. Facebook has recently doubled down on Influencer Marketing with a full Creator Marketplace for marketers to find and work with top talent.

It’s not just a buzzword marketing tactic either, the numbers back it up

“Research from Meta for Business in 2020 found that 84% of global consumers say they would purchase, try or recommend a product based on influencer content if it is relevant.

Influencer marketing is especially powerful in driving sales when paired with other ads. Facebook and Instagram campaigns that combined regular ads and influencer ads are 85%3 more likely to drive people to add products to shopping carts, compared with using regular ads alone, according to 2021 Meta for Business research…For brands, the most effective influencers to partner with are those seen as authentic, trustworthy and relatable by their audiences. In fact, 60% of global consumers say they’d follow a brand, product or service after seeing it promoted by a creator who shares their values and interests.

2.) Put a Face to Your Brand

It’s incredibly rare for a brand to build sustainable success through advertising alone. It takes branding and marketing to drive awareness and make people familiar with what a business is offering. Putting a face to your brand helps create a connection, build a community and a sense of trust, but most importantly it arouses emotion.

“Emotions drive people to action. They make us laugh, shout, and cry, and they make us talk, share, and buy.” – Contagious: Why Things Catch On

3.) You Have to Give Before You Can Ask

In the era of privacy concerns online, trust takes time to build between brand and consumer. It’s important to understand that you can’t always be looking to sell, especially not in the first interaction with a user. Provide content that’s meaningful, educational, informative, and entertaining. Connect with your target audience and build a tribe of users that want to be associated with your brand. Provide more than you ask for so when you do go for the ask, users are ready, willing, and able.

4.) Differentiate Your Content

Too many brands create one piece of content and then share the same exact thing on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, LinkedIn etc. It isn’t just a recommendation anymore, it is vital to differentiate your content. 

Give people a reason to follow and engage with you on different platforms or you run the risk of siloing your audiences. Create native content for each platform in order to reach the user where they are, but more importantly reach them with content that speaks to the behavior of the specific platform.

5.) Become More Than Transactional. 

Provide value beyond just the product you hope to sell if you want to build a lasting relationship with customers. For a brick and mortar business that might mean selling coffee in the morning to reach customers at different times of the day while eliciting different behaviors. 

Another example of becoming more than transactional is the renowned customer service of e-commerce pet retailer Chewy. With big box stores, Amazon, and local pet stores it’s difficult to cut through the white noise when many customers are just comparing prices. Chewy became more than transactional with its personal touch in customer service.

With articles appearing on the likes of Fortune and the Today Show, the customer service interactions of Chewy include not just refunds, but handwritten notes and even flowers delivered to customer’s doors.

Customers will remember you and more importantly talk about you if the relationship becomes more than a transaction.

Split Testing is Now Available on Facebook

screen-shot-2016-10-21-at-9-13-22-am

Facebook is now starting to roll out Split Testing in Ads Manager, which is essentially an easier way to test different variables in ad campaigns to see which ones perform the best. In the past you would have to run separate ad sets to perform tests like this, but wasn’t necessarily a pure A/B test. This is something that Google AdWords has offered for some time, allowing campaigns to experiment and split test. It’s a much welcomed addition to the Ads Manager as one strategy, targeting method, or ad objective that works great for one campaign doesn’t necessarily work the same for others.

So if you’re still having internal debates over whether this ad campaign should optimize for Website Clicks or Conversions, now you can run a split test and see which actually does the best. Learn what works the best for different campaigns and maybe you’ll unearth something totally unexpected.

Have you ever wanted to easily test the same ad on two different audiences to see which performed better? Or maybe you’d like to figure out which optimization type yields the best results, optimizing for Conversions or Link Clicks? Advertisers run tests to identify the best ad performance on Facebook, Instagram and Audience Network and to understand how changes in different aspects of their ad can impact ad performance. Tests like this need to be set up fairly so that advertisers can understand the true impact of their ad strategies on the performance of their ads.

Store Visits Tracking from Facebook Hits the Shelves

screen-shot-2016-09-15-at-3-16-17-pm

Unless you’re a big brand or agency, you probably haven’t gotten direct access yet to Store Visits tracking on Google or Facebook. It looks like Facebook is now rolling out their version of the metric with a new ad objective.

“With over 90% of all transactions still taking place offline, driving customers into a store, restaurant, auto dealership or other place of business remains a primary marketing objective for any advertiser with brick-and-mortar locations.”

Essentially the feature allows you to determine how many users visited your business location after clicking on a Facebook ad. While this is exciting news to anyone that advertises on Facebook, there are minimum thresholds that need to be met before FB will grant eligibility.

screen-shot-2016-09-15-at-3-18-28-pm

This has been something marketers have been craving for as long as digital has been driving sales. Everyone has micro-moments, everyone does research online and many people make purchases online, but what about the people that just go into a store to make the final purchase? If not attributed directly or proper expectations are not set, marketers can oftentimes be left out to dry by the gap in data. So while it remains to be seen how well this new ad type will work, it is quite exciting for any brick and mortar locations.

“This objective has been specifically created for brick and mortar businesses who want to reach customers in the right location, with localized ad content and the ultimate goal of driving customers in-store. Additionally, over the next couple weeks, we are rolling out enhancements to the Store Visits objective which will allow you to not only report on store visits, but optimize your ads towards those most likely to visit.”

Facebook is describing this as the “Evolution of Local Awareness on Facebook and Instagram.” They might be right.

How to Uncover (Direct/None) Referral Traffic in Google Analytics

logo_lockup_analytics_icon_horizontal_black_2x

Have you noticed in your client’s Google Analytics that certain sources are not being identified clearly in Source traffic? One of the best ways to alleviate this issue is to use URL Parameters modifiers to essentially call out where the traffic is coming from. This helps GA tag the traffic coming in and sorting it into its own specific source, which allows you to identify and confirm the referral source.

screen-shot-2016-09-08-at-8-01-45-pm

This is an issue I know most marketers are aware of as (Direct/None) traffic can be a number of things. It’s not very likely that every one of your customers is typing in the long, specific URL every single time though. What’s more likely is that Google doesn’t know exactly how to sort the traffic or identify where it’s coming from.

I recently identified this issue for a website who’s Facebook tracking wasn’t firing and Analytics wasn’t reporting much referral traffic coming from Facebook, despite plenty of paid ad clicks. So looking through GA you’re likely to notice a large portion of traffic from Direct/None and while it’s unlikely to ever uncover 100% of the unknown traffic, you can tag URL’s from traffic that you know you’re driving, to help close the loop.

So how do you accomplish this? Below are a few quick steps to use URL Parameters to tag your traffic for GA to more easily sort. Note, this specific example was for tagging Facebook referral traffic.

1.) Identify that your ad traffic definitely isn’t being reported accurately in Google Analytics.

2.) Pull the URL of wherever you are driving traffic (i.e. example.com/product)

3.) In the case of Facebook, you’ll add the following URL Parameter at the end of the url:

?source=facebook (i.e. example.com/product?source=facebook)

4.) Copy and paste that URL into your browser to make sure it doesn’t cause any errors or unexpected reroutes.

5.) After sufficient clicks on your ad using this URL Parameter, go into your Google Analytics > Behavior > Content > All Pages. This will allow you to see what pages all of your users are landing on.

6.) Using the URL Parameter you set up earlier you can identify that specific landing page (example.com/product?source=facebook), which you’ve tagged as coming from a specific source. In this case it’s a Facebook ad, so GA will sort out that traffic and label it with the new URL so you can easily identify this traffic is in fact coming from your Facebook ad — breaking it out of the ambiguous Direct distinction.

You’ve now uncovered your referral traffic out of (Direct/None) in Google Analytics!